From Solo to Group Practice: The Financial Checklist Before You Hire Your First Clinician

Solo to Group Practice

If you have a waitlist you can’t get through, and you keep thinking, “maybe it’s time to hire someone,” you are right on schedule. Almost every solo therapist who fills up reaches this point.

What usually comes next is a lot of thinking about the clinical side. Who to hire, how to supervise them, what the job posting should say. The money side gets a quick “we’ll figure it out,” and that’s the part that tends to bite.

So here is the financial checklist when going from solo to group practice that we’d want you to run through before you post that listing. 

None of it is hard… it just needs to happen in the right order.

Can Your Practice Revenue Carry Your First Clinician?

When it’s just you, the math is simple. Sessions come in, overhead goes out, and what’s left is yours.

A new clinician changes that. Your revenue now has to cover their pay, the extra costs that come with them, and still leave room for your own paycheck. It also has to do that while they’re still building a caseload, which takes months, not weeks.

So ask yourself this: if your new hire saw very few clients for the first few months, could the practice still pay them and you? Use the money that actually landed in your bank account, not what you billed, because insurance payments have a habit of arriving late and light.

If the honest answer is “maybe,” that’s worth a conversation with your accountant before you make an offer.

W-2 or 1099: How To Classify Your First Clinician

Before anything else, you need to know whether this person will be an employee (W-2) or an independent contractor (1099). This isn’t a preference you get to pick. It depends on how the working relationship actually runs.

If you set their schedule, send them your clients, and have them use your systems and paperwork, they’re almost certainly an employee. A true contractor runs their own business and decides how and when the work gets done. The IRS looks at who controls the work, not what the contract calls it.

That’s why most group practices end up with W-2 clinicians. Getting it wrong can mean back taxes, penalties, and interest later, so settle this one first. Our 1099 vs. W-2 guide for therapists goes deeper on what the IRS looks for.

The Real Cost Of Hiring A W-2 Clinician

The salary you offer is only the starting number. On top of it, you pay the employer’s half of their Social Security and Medicare taxes, plus federal and state unemployment taxes. Most states also require workers’ comp insurance, and then there are any benefits you choose to offer.

A 1099 contractor skips all of that, which is why it looks cheaper on paper. It only stays cheaper if the arrangement genuinely qualifies, and most group practice setups don’t.

This is the one spot where you want a real number instead of a guess. Our breakdown of what hiring your first therapist really costs walks through it line by line.

Does Your Practice Entity Need To Change Before You Hire?

Usually not. You can have employees as a sole proprietor or a single-member PLLC, so hiring on its own doesn’t force a new structure.

What does change is the paperwork. You’ll need an Employer Identification Number, or EIN, which is the tax ID the IRS uses for your practice, if you don’t have one already. You’ll also register with your state as an employer.

Hiring is also a good moment to look at the S-corp question again, since you’re about to be running payroll anyway. Our S-Corp vs. PLLC calculator for therapists runs it on your own numbers before you take it to your accountant.

Your retirement plan deserves the same second look. A solo 401(k) is designed for owners without employees, so your first hire can change whether it still fits. If you’re still solo for now, our rundown of solo 401(k) setup deadlines covers the timing you’ll want to know. It’s worth raising with your accountant before you make an offer.

And if your business and personal money still overlap even a little, split them now. Once someone else’s paycheck comes out of that account, it needs to be clean.

Set Up Payroll Before Your First Clinician Starts

Payroll isn’t something to sort out after their first day. It needs to be running, with the right amounts withheld, from the very first paycheck.

Getting there means your EIN, a state employer account, a payroll service, and a pay schedule. On day one, your new hire fills out a Form W-4 so you know how much tax to withhold, and a Form I-9 to confirm they can work in the U.S. Your state will also want you to report the new hire shortly after they start.

A payroll service like Gusto handles most of the mechanics. It works out the withholding, makes the tax deposits, files your payroll tax returns, and sends W-2s at year-end. That matters, because payroll tax deposits have specific due dates and missing them comes with penalties.

Group Practice Bookkeeping Has To Grow Up Too

Solo bookkeeping can survive being a little messy. Group practice bookkeeping can’t, because now there’s a payroll cycle and sessions billed under more than one provider.

The big new need is tracking revenue by clinician, not just for the practice as a whole. That’s how you’ll know whether a hire is covering their cost, and when it might be time for the next one.

Get your books caught up before you hire. Our bare minimum bookkeeping guide covers what needs to be in place before things get busier.

Your Cash Cushion For The First 90 Days Of Group Practice

The first few months after your first hire are usually the tightest. Their caseload is still building, but their paycheck starts on day one. You’re also spending time on onboarding, credentialing, and billing setup that doesn’t bring in any money.

Practices that come through this comfortably usually have two to three months of operating expenses set aside before the hire. That cushion covers payroll during the ramp-up without you having to cut your own pay. If it isn’t there yet, building it first is worth the wait.

If you already use Profit First, it’s worth revisiting your allocations once payroll starts. Our guide to Profit First for group practice owners covers what changes when you add W-2 therapists.

This window is also when you’ll find out whether your fees can support a group practice. If you’ve been meaning to revisit them, do it before you hire. Our guide to setting fees in private practice walks through how to think about it.

You don’t need every answer before you start looking. You just need to know the money side is ready for a second person, and that’s something we can check together in one conversation.

If your first hire is on the horizon, let’s chat, and we’ll look at your numbers with you.

TL;DR:

Before you hire your first clinician, make sure your revenue can carry them through a slow start, you know whether they’re W-2 or 1099, payroll is running before day one, and you have two to three months of expenses set aside.

Khaled - TLDR

Khaled Albadawi, CPA

Principal & CEO

Khaled joined TL;DR as Principal in December of 2022, and has quickly hit the ground running offering a fresh new perspective for the TL;DR team and clients. He’s a natural entrepreneur & leader, starting his days at 4 AM with a nice cup of coffee to get a jumpstart on projects before the business world wakes up. His one piece of advice to business owners? Ask yourself if you are creating just another job or a business. Ideally, you should be building something that doesn’t require you to be there 40 hours a week!

you may also like:

Vector 3 (2) (1)

ready to work with us?

You can schedule your introductory chat: